Gem Gains

Best Rookie Cards to Grade Right Now

Rookie years drive the biggest PSA 10 spreads in the hobby. These are the top rookie cards to grade across all four majors — ranked weekly by live net profit after grading and sale fees. Updated 9/7/2026.

16 tracked rookies · Fees modeled: $25 PSA + 13% sale.

NFLTop NFL Rookies to Grade

  1. 1

    Cam Ward 2025 Prizm Base #10

    Tennessee Titans

    Raw
    $1,000
    PSA 10
    $4,250
    Net
    $2,673
  2. 2

    Tetairoa McMillan 2025 Prizm Base #7

    Carolina Panthers

    Raw
    $830
    PSA 10
    $3,520
    Net
    $2,207
  3. 3

    Ashton Jeanty 2025 Prizm Base #4

    Las Vegas Raiders

    Raw
    $825
    PSA 10
    $3,236
    Net
    $1,965
  4. 4

    Travis Hunter 2025 Prizm Base #8

    Jacksonville Jaguars

    Raw
    $1,275
    PSA 10
    $5,391
    Net
    $3,390
  5. 5

    Ashton Jeanty 2025 Select Zebra Prizm Shock #4

    Las Vegas Raiders

    Raw
    $217
    PSA 10
    $1,006
    Net
    $633
  6. 6

    Tetairoa McMillan 2025 Panini Optic Base

    Carolina Panthers

    Raw
    $207
    PSA 10
    $1,000
    Net
    $638

NBATop NBA Rookies to Grade

  1. 1

    Cooper Flagg 2025 Hoops Base #BO-10

    Dallas Mavericks

    Raw
    $203
    PSA 10
    $956
    Net
    $604
  2. 2

    Cooper Flagg 2025 Hoops Base #BYB-1

    Dallas Mavericks

    Raw
    $184
    PSA 10
    $870
    Net
    $548
  3. 3

    Dylan Harper 2025 Hoops Rainbow Purple Blue #7

    San Antonio Spurs

    Raw
    $100
    PSA 10
    $340
    Net
    $170
  4. 4

    Cooper Flagg 2025 Hoops Pixel Burst #35

    Dallas Mavericks

    Raw
    $51
    PSA 10
    $247
    Net
    $138
  5. 5

    Dylan Harper 2025 Hoops Base #HRS-D

    San Antonio Spurs

    Raw
    $240
    PSA 10
    $1,151
    Net
    $737

NHLTop NHL Rookies to Grade

  1. 1

    Alex Ovechkin 2024 Upper Deck Young Guns Exclusive #YGR-13

    —

    Raw
    $252
    PSA 10
    $929
    Net
    $532
  2. 2

    Macklin Celebrini 2024 Upper Deck Young Guns Base #451

    San Jose Sharks

    Raw
    $145
    PSA 10
    $671
    Net
    $413
  3. 3

    Macklin Celebrini 2024 Upper Deck Base #C360

    San Jose Sharks

    Raw
    $563
    PSA 10
    $1,344
    Net
    $581
  4. 4

    Macklin Celebrini 2024 O-Pee-Chee Rainbow Black #545

    San Jose Sharks

    Raw
    $320
    PSA 10
    $1,072
    Net
    $588
  5. 5

    Macklin Celebrini 2024 Upper Deck Outburst Silver #743

    San Jose Sharks

    Raw
    $222
    PSA 10
    $787
    Net
    $438
  6. 6

    Macklin Celebrini 2025 O-Pee-Chee Base #WO-1

    San Jose Sharks

    Raw
    $201
    PSA 10
    $953
    Net
    $603

Keep exploring

Track every rookie's buy window in one place.

Free 14-day trial · No credit card required.